Why the Best Decisions Are Never Perfect

The shift from ‘right’ to ‘safe-to-try’ decisions

Where the wind is blowing next we don’t know. – Pic by Nicole Wilcox

“In business, if you realize you’ve made a bad decision, you change it.”

— Richard Branson

Making decisions is like freedom. Everybody wants it, but they don’t know what to do once they get it.

In most organizations, making decision equals to having power. And that’s why people want to make the call. However, when they are tasked to make a decision, most people freeze and do nothing. They mimic their bosses’ behaviors.

Making decisions requires courage, not power.

You don’t need a title or someone else’s support to make things happen. You need clarity to make the call. And the courage to pull the trigger when the rest is afraid of failing.

However, when coaching teams, I usually observe how fear takes over excitement. Those who wish they could make the call, don’t want to be exposed.

Why Managers Fail to Make Decisions

“You can’t make decisions based on fear and the possibility of what might happen.”
― Michelle Obama

Some executives are excellent strategists; others are great executors. Very few play well at the intersection between planning and acting: making decisions. Here’s why.

Emotions beat logic:

Neuroscientist Antonio Damasio discovered that people with damage in the part of the brain where emotions are generated, couldn’t make simple decisions. Shall I have chicken or turkey?

With no connection to their feelings, these test subjects weren’t able to decide.

Your gut and heart are as important as your brain, listen to all your ‘brains’ when making a decision.

Low self-esteem:

Most managers delegate tasks, but not authority. They tell their teams: “you are in charge now,” but don’t let go of the final approval. The inability to ‘share’ power is driven by lack of confidence, not lack of leadership training as many HR folks think.

Delegating authority is an act of generosity.

Executives don’t delegate ‘power’ when they are concerned about their own reputation or pride, rather than doing what’s right for the organization.

Information Overburden:

Risk-avoidance is the greatest paradox of decision-making. Analysis can help you eliminate unnecessary options. But making decisions requires taking risks.

Once you make a choice, you are saying ‘yes’ to the consequences too.

With so much information available, we can prove any theory right or wrong. Information overload can drive confusion rather than clarity. In most of the cases, an excess of analysis can become a distraction to put off making a decision.

Fear of failure:

Decisions can have unexpected consequences. That’s why most managers fall prey to indecision: they are afraid of failing. Being fearful of risking their reputation makes them deaf.

When you listen to your fears, you stop listening to your gut and common sense.

Fear is anticipation to a future that we are not sure it will happen.

Stop Finding the Right Decision

“If you obsess over whether you are making the right decision, you are basically assuming that the universe will reward you for one thing and punish you for another.”

— Deepak Chopra

There’s no such a thing as a perfect decision. As Pearl Zhu says: “It is often said that a wrong decision taken at the right time is better than a right decision taken at the wrong time.”

The perfect time to make decisions is now. Taking time to reflect and clarify your thoughts is goods. You shouldn’t rush making decisions. But if letting something stew becomes a never-ending process, then you are in trouble.

Perfectionism is the enemy of change, as I wrote here. Some teams spend meeting after meeting discussing their issues rather than solving them. Overthinking is avoidance.

Most decisions are not perfect. But they drive action, unlike indecision.

“So. Tell me. What do you think? Which is better? To take action and perhaps make a fatal mistake — or to take no action and die slowly anyway?”
― Ahdaf Soueif

Take the plunge. That’s the first step. You can always course correct. Action drives excitement. And it’s much better than watching other teams create stuff while yours continues to rehash possible outcomes.

If you are not taking risks, you are not making a decision. You are just playing safe.

Courage moves teams forward, not power.

Aiming for the perfect solution is the opposite. Inaction gets teams stuck.

Safe to Try is the New Right

“If you never try, you’ll never know.” — Coldplay

The most successful teams are those that can adapt to a changing environment. That requires a mindset shift: from a perfectionist to an experimental one, among others.

The best way to minimize risk is to make decisions in small doses.

“Safe-to-try” decisions drive action rather than waiting for the perfect solution to arrive. Their purpose is to implement and then course correct based on real feedback rather than on hypothesis based on fear and anticipation.

Think of it as a Litmus test. To accept or reject a proposal there are two questions to consider:

  • “Will this decision move the team backward?”
  • “Will the proposal, if implemented, cause harm which can not be mitigated promptly?”

The purpose of these questions is not just to validate the proposal, but to avoid personal bias and speculation. Do you have any objection (not opinions)?

Objections need to be based on facts and information in the present, not future tensions.

Safe-to-try decisions are built on the following principles:

  • Inaction can be more harmful than a decision that is not perfect
  • Decisions are not definite
  • You can always course correct based on real-life feedback
  • Build a habit of making small dose decisions

When teams get stuck and can’t pull the trigger, I always ask: What’s the worst that can happen?

Stop waiting for the perfect decision. Embrace an experimental mindset. Think of your decisions as a prototype that can always be improved.

“All the time a wind is blowing. Where it’s blowing next, we don’t know…”

— Anthony Philips

Realizing that they cannot anticipate the future is hard for most executives. They were trained and wired to know and control. But, more often than not, things take a life of their own.

Failing is a possibility, fear of failing is not.

The magic of the safe-to-try method is demystifying decision-making. However, commitment still plays a significant role. There’s no room for fears or second thoughts. Even ‘small-dose decisions’ need to be treated seriously.

The outcome of most decisions relies more on the support and conviction behind it than on the decision itself.

There’s no such a thing as the perfect time or choice.

The best decision is the one you make with determination. Not the one you keep putting off because it’s not perfect.

Upgrade Your Team’s Adaptability

Subscribe to our Insights for Changemakers: Sign Up Now

If you want to learn more about how a safe-to-try approach can accelerate change at your organization, feel free to reach out.